Reboot Alberta

Thursday, May 29, 2008

Harper's Old-School Politics of Command and Control Could be His Demise.

Lawrence Martin of the Globe and Mail is my favourite national political columnists. His analysis today about Stephen Harper leadership style and character and comments of Mr. Harper’s former mentor, Preston Manning are worth reading and pondering.


The man is all about tight command and control by the PMO. He applies it to everyone in the Harper government. The default talking point of every Conservative in Ottawa is to reference the sponsorship scandal. That is an old storyline that Canadians have moved beyond. However it is trotted out every time as the answer to any criticism directed at the Cons political, governance and statesmanship gaffe and shortcoming.


This centralized micromanaging and macro messaging control is Harper himself is bound to run its limits and try the patience of the voter. The sponsorship scandal as the Harper Cons answer to all issues is past frustrating, was never funny and now shows just how futile the Harper Cons are at real governing.

I love this African proverb and often think of it when I reflect on Mr. Harper as our pro tem PM. "If want to go fast, go alone. If you want to go far, go with others." I like to add, if you want to do both you better transform the culture and find consensus. Tranfixing on dictating from the top will not go fast or far.


The Harper minority government has run its course. Unfortunately the Dion alternative is not seen as viable either. It is time for a different political approach and a different kind of person in politics. Given the nature of the job and the little upside for citizens to actually run for office, we may have ot wait a long time for that kind of change to occur.

2 comments:

  1. Whooee! Well KenFeller, we ain't gonna elect PM Lizzie May or PM Jack Layton. He may not be much but Dion's lookin' better an' better versus Harper all the time.

    I think the Grits can pull off a minority. What I'm noticing is a much greater willingness to have the Grits fronted by well-spoken guys like Iggy, Goodale and Rae. That thing last week where they said teh Lib's are rallyin' around Dion and his carbon tax looks like it might actually be workin'.

    If the Grits can go out and sell tax-shiftin' on teh BBQ circuit this summer and Harper's shallow talent pool continues to bellyflop, the Grits got a chance.

    Of course, we need a few Greens in there next time, too. If we can get Lizzie on the TV debates, we can win seats. Central Nova's lookin' better and better as the Con's are foundering and Petey MacKay's chances are gettin' slimmer.

    Long term change is what us Greens have been about for a long time. We know we ain't gonna form the gummint anytime soon, if ever. We been patiently working and building support for green initiatives. The fact that we seem to have won Dion and the Grits over to our tax shift policy is dang encouraging.

    JB

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous8:30 pm

    "Unfortunately the Dion alternative is not seen as viable either."

    That is an understatement. Even with the 'natural governing party', people are rejecting his ideas and so-called leadership. Even David McGuinty slammed Dion on his precious carbon tax - this will greatly hurt Dion's chances in Ontario outside Toronto.

    ReplyDelete

Anonymous comments are discouraged. If you have something to say, the rest of us have to know who you are